Buyer's guide

AEO RFP template: how to brief, score and compare AEO and GEO agencies

An AEO RFP is a short written brief that asks several AEO or GEO agencies to propose the same scope, measured the same way, so you can compare their method, reporting and price side by side. The version below gives you the ten sections to include, the questions that separate practitioners from resellers, a weighted scoring sheet with a worked example, a pricing format that makes bids comparable and the red flags to watch for. It is written for marketing leads, founders and heads of growth who are about to spend real budget on AI search.

Get a free AEO visibility check

Two lines is enough. A specialist replies within one business day.

An AEO specialist replies from info@aeoservicesagency.com, usually within one business day. No mailing lists.

Updated November 20, 2026 · by Harsh Khubchandani, Founder, Greenwolf Tech Labs

The short answer

What should an AEO RFP include?

An AEO RFP should include your goals, the engines and markets that matter, a prompt set you own, the current baseline, the scope you want priced, questions on method and measurement, required first-party reporting, team and terms, a fixed pricing format, and published scoring weights with a response deadline. Without the prompt set and baseline, bids cannot be compared.

Quotable points

  • Build and own the prompt set and baseline before you send the RFP.
  • Ask every bidder to price the same line items in the same format.
  • Score method and measurement highest; a low price with a vague method is the riskiest bid.
  • Any response that promises a citation or a top position should be marked down.
Illustration: how Google AI Overview can answer a buyer question and cite your site. Example only; no real result shown.
01

What is an AEO RFP, and when do you need one?

An AEO RFP is a request for proposal for answer engine and generative engine work: getting your brand named and cited in ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, Perplexity, Copilot, Gemini and Claude. Use one when the spend is large enough that a wrong choice costs a quarter, or when procurement requires a formal process. A GEO RFP is the same document under a different label; agencies use the two acronyms for overlapping work.

The demand for a written process is recent. Seer Interactive published 27 GEO RFP questions in August 2026 and ESEOspace published a GEO and AEO RFP template in October 2026, and both stress the same problem: proposals that cannot be compared. It matters because buyers have already moved: a G2 survey of 1,076 software buyers in March 2026 found 51% start software research in an AI chatbot more often than in Google. Picking the wrong partner now costs real pipeline.

You do not always need a full RFP. If you only want a one-off AEO audit, asking two or three firms for a fixed-price proposal against a one-page brief is enough. The light version at the end of this guide covers that case. Reserve the full RFP for ongoing programs, multi-market work or anything that needs sign-off beyond marketing.

02

What should you prepare before writing the AEO RFP?

Prepare three things you will keep regardless of who wins: a prompt set, a baseline and a list of known technical issues. If every bidder measures against their own private prompts, each proposal shows a different starting point and none of them can be checked later.

Write 30 to 60 buyer prompts grouped by stage: category questions ("best payroll software for restaurants"), comparisons naming your real competitors, problem questions, pricing and alternatives questions, and a few branded prompts. Run each prompt in the engines your buyers use, record whether you are named and which URLs are cited, and save the date. Answers vary between runs, and Semrush found only 25% of cited sources overlap between ChatGPT's reasoning modes, so run each prompt more than once and keep the averages.

Then export the first-party numbers: the generative AI performance report Google added to Search Console in June 2026, Bing Webmaster Tools AI Performance with its citation share view, and a GA4 segment for referrals from chatgpt.com, perplexity.ai, copilot.microsoft.com and gemini.google.com. Finally, check AI crawler access: confirm in robots.txt, your CDN settings and server logs that OAI-SearchBot, PerplexityBot, Claude-SearchBot, Googlebot and Bingbot receive HTTP 200 responses. If they do not, say so in the RFP; it changes what the first month should be.

03

What sections should an AEO RFP template include?

Ten sections cover it. Keep the whole document under eight pages; agencies that read it carefully will ask questions, and those questions tell you a lot. Copy the list below into your own template and fill in each heading.

  • 1. About us: what you sell, to whom, in which countries and languages, and who decides.
  • 2. Why now: the business problem, for example AI Overviews taking clicks, competitors named in ChatGPT answers, or wrong AI answers about your pricing.
  • 3. Engines and markets in scope: list them, ranked by importance to your buyers.
  • 4. Current state: the prompt set, the baseline results and the first-party exports, attached.
  • 5. Scope to be priced: audit, technical fixes, content restructuring, off-site mention work, measurement, enablement. Mark each as required or optional.
  • 6. Method questions: how they diagnose, prioritize and decide what to change first.
  • 7. Measurement and reporting: the metrics, sources and cadence you require (see below).
  • 8. Team: who does the work, their time on your account, and what is outsourced.
  • 9. Pricing and terms: the fixed pricing table, contract length, notice period, and ownership of prompts, data and content.
  • 10. Process: question deadline, response deadline, format, shortlist dates, decision date and the scoring weights.
04

Which questions should an AEO RFP ask agencies?

Ask questions that force a specific answer, not a capabilities brochure. The best ones ask the agency to apply its method to your baseline, which a reseller of generic SEO packages cannot do well.

Google's own guidance says optimizing for generative AI search is still SEO and that no special files or markup are needed, so ask how each bidder handles that. A strong answer explains what they do beyond standard SEO and why; a weak one sells llms.txt or schema markup as the main lever.

  • Looking at our baseline, which three prompts would you work on first, and why those?
  • For one prompt where a competitor is cited and we are not, what do you think explains it, and how would you confirm that?
  • What would you change on our site in the first 30 days, and what happens off-site?
  • Which first-party reports will you use for Google, Bing and AI referral traffic, and which third-party tracker, if any?
  • How do you handle run-to-run variation in AI answers when you report progress?
  • How do you separate AI visibility changes from normal SEO changes and seasonality?
  • Who on your team writes the content and who handles technical fixes? Is any of it subcontracted?
  • What would make you tell us to stop or change scope?
  • What do you need from us each month, in hours and approvals?
  • Which tactics will you not use, and why?
05

How should you score AEO RFP responses?

Publish the weights in the RFP and score each response from 1 to 5 per criterion, then convert to a weighted total out of 100. Weight method and measurement highest, because those are where AEO bids differ most and where a weak agency wastes the most time.

The worked example below is illustrative: three hypothetical bidders scored by the same panel. Agency B quoted the lowest price but promised a top position in ChatGPT and gave no measurement plan, so it lost despite winning on cost. Agency A had the strongest reporting but a vague first 90 days and a long lock-in. Agency C won on balance. Each weighted score is the 1 to 5 score divided by 5, multiplied by the weight.

Criterion (weight)Agency AAgency BAgency C
Method and diagnosis (25)4 = 202 = 104 = 20
Measurement and reporting (25)5 = 252 = 104 = 20
Fit with scope, engines and industry (15)3 = 94 = 124 = 12
Team and who does the work (10)3 = 63 = 64 = 8
Price and price clarity (15)2 = 65 = 154 = 12
Terms and ownership (10)3 = 62 = 45 = 10
Weighted total (100)725782
06

How do you make AEO agency pricing comparable?

Give bidders a pricing table with fixed line items and ask them to fill it in, adding notes but not changing the rows. Proposals that bundle everything into one monthly figure hide how much goes to measurement versus actual changes, and you cannot cut scope later without renegotiating.

For realistic budget ranges before you send the RFP, our guide to AEO pricing collects the rates agencies publish. State a budget band in the RFP if you can; it saves every bidder from guessing and gives you proposals sized to what you can spend.

Line itemAsk forWhy it matters
AEO audit and prompt-set reviewFixed fee, with deliverables listedShows whether diagnosis is real work or a template
Technical fixes (crawler access, rendering, indexing)Fixed fee or capped hoursOften one-off; should not sit in a retainer forever
Content restructuringPrice per page or per batchLets you scale up or down by results
Off-site mentions and digital PRMonthly fee with named activitiesThe hardest work to verify; insist on specifics
Measurement and monthly reportMonthly fee, tracker cost shown separatelySeparates reporting from doing
Team enablement or consultingHourly or per sessionOptional; useful if you plan to bring work in-house
07

What red flags show up in GEO RFP responses?

Most weak responses fail in predictable ways. Mark them down hard, because each one usually signals how the engagement would run.

  • Promising a citation, a mention or a top position in a named engine. No one can promise a citation; engines decide and answers change between runs.
  • No mention of your baseline. If the proposal could have been sent to any company, it was.
  • Measurement only through the agency's own dashboard, with no Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools or GA4 data.
  • llms.txt, schema or a proprietary score presented as the main lever.
  • Bulk AI-written pages as the core content plan, or seeding fake reviews and Reddit posts. Google advises against inauthentic mentions, and both put your brand at risk.
  • Long minimum terms with no exit after a first diagnostic phase.
  • Prompts, logs or content that stay the agency's property when you leave.
08

What does a realistic AEO RFP timeline look like?

Plan five to seven weeks from baseline to decision. Goodie's AI search RFP guide suggests three to six weeks for complex projects; the extra week here is the baseline you build before issuing the RFP, which makes every later step faster.

Week 0: build the prompt set, run the baseline and export first-party reports. Week 1: issue the RFP to four to six agencies. Week 2: questions due, with every answer shared with all bidders. Week 4: proposals due. Week 5: shortlist two or three for a working session where they walk through one of your prompts live. Week 6: decision, references checked, contract signed.

For a smaller team or a one-off audit, use a light RFP: one page with sections 2, 3, 4 and 5, the pricing table cut to the first two rows, and three of the questions above. Send it to two or three firms you found through referrals or a best aeo agency shortlist, and decide in two weeks.

09

What should happen after you choose an agency?

The first 30 days should confirm the baseline, fix access and indexing problems, and agree the first content and mention priorities with dates. By day 90 you should see a change log, a re-run of the same prompt set and first-party trends, even if citation gains are still modest. Put those checkpoints in the contract.

Keep ownership clear: the prompt set, the raw run logs and every page written for you belong to you. That lets you switch agencies, bring work in-house or move to an ongoing AI search optimization program without losing your history.

If you would like a proposal to test your RFP against, AEO Services Agency, the AEO and GEO practice of Greenwolf Tech Labs, starts with a free AEO visibility check. Every engagement is fixed-price, and we measure the same prompt set before and after changes so the results can be checked. We will answer your RFP in your format, and we will not promise placements anyone cannot control.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between an AEO RFP and a GEO RFP?

Very little. AEO (answer engine optimization) and GEO (generative engine optimization) describe overlapping work on getting cited in AI answers. Use whichever term your team and bidders use, and define the engines and scope in the document so the label does not matter.

How many agencies should receive an AEO RFP?

Four to six is enough for a full RFP, and two or three for a light one. More than six makes fair scoring hard, and the best agencies may decline long processes with many bidders.

Should I include a budget in the RFP?

Yes, as a range. A budget band lets bidders size the scope to what you can spend, so proposals are comparable. Without it, you get a mix of minimal and maximal plans that are hard to score.

Can an agency promise our brand will appear in ChatGPT or AI Overviews?

No. AI engines choose sources themselves and answers change between runs, so no one can promise a citation. Treat any such promise as a red flag and look instead for a clear method, a baseline and first-party measurement.

What metrics should an AEO RFP require agencies to report?

Mention and citation rates on your fixed prompt set, by engine, plus first-party data: the Search Console generative AI report, Bing Webmaster Tools AI Performance and GA4 referrals from AI assistants. Ask for a monthly change log so movements can be tied to specific work.

How long should an AEO agency contract be?

A common structure is a fixed-price diagnostic phase of four to eight weeks, then a rolling or short-term program with a clear notice period. Avoid long lock-ins before the agency has shown a baseline, a plan and early fixes.

Do I need an RFP for a one-off AEO audit?

Usually not. A one-page brief with your goals, engines, a sample of prompts and a request for a fixed price and deliverables list is enough. Compare two or three proposals and check what each audit actually examines.

Reviewed by Team Greenwolf Tech Labs · 20 Nov 2026

Explore

Find your industry and market

Get started

Find out what AI says about you

Send your website and three questions your buyers ask. Within one business day we reply with how ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity answer them today, who they cite instead of you, and a fixed-price plan.

  • Free AEO visibility check
  • Fixed quote before any work starts
  • Measured on citations and AI referrals, not promises

Prefer email? info@aeoservicesagency.com

Get a free AEO visibility check

Two lines is enough to start.

An AEO specialist replies from info@aeoservicesagency.com, usually within one business day. No mailing lists.

Ask us anything

An AEO specialist replies from info@aeoservicesagency.com, usually within one business day.

An AEO specialist replies from info@aeoservicesagency.com, usually within one business day. No mailing lists.